Table of Contents
The world of anime often brings adaptations that vary significantly from their source material. One of the most notable examples of this phenomenon is the adaptation of Hiromu Arakawa’s manga, “Fullmetal Alchemist.” The two major adaptations, “Fullmetal Alchemist” and “Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood,” showcase distinct differences in storytelling, character development, and thematic elements. This article explores the canonical differences between these two adaptations, providing insights into how they interpret the original manga.
Overview of Fullmetal Alchemist
First serialized in 2001, “Fullmetal Alchemist” follows the journey of two brothers, Edward and Alphonse Elric, who use alchemy in their quest to restore their bodies after a failed transmutation. The original anime adaptation aired from 2003 to 2004, diverging from the manga’s storyline due to the manga’s ongoing publication at the time.
Overview of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
In contrast, “Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood” premiered in 2009 and closely follows the manga’s narrative, providing a more faithful adaptation of Arakawa’s work. This series encompasses the complete story arc, allowing for a more comprehensive exploration of themes and character arcs.
Canonical Differences
While both adaptations share core characters and themes, several key differences shape their narratives and character portrayals.
Story Arcs
The original “Fullmetal Alchemist” diverges significantly from the manga’s plot midway through the series. It introduces original characters and storylines that are not present in the manga. In contrast, “Brotherhood” adheres to the manga’s structure, ensuring that the story develops as intended by the author.
Character Development
Character development is another area where the two adaptations differ. In “Fullmetal Alchemist,” certain characters, such as Scar and the homunculi, are given different backstories and motivations. “Brotherhood,” however, offers a more nuanced portrayal of these characters, providing deeper insights into their motivations and relationships.
Thematic Elements
The themes of sacrifice, redemption, and the consequences of one’s actions are prominent in both adaptations. However, “Brotherhood” delves deeper into these themes, exploring the philosophical implications of alchemy and the moral dilemmas faced by the characters. The original series, while touching on these themes, often shifts focus towards action and adventure.
Character Comparisons
Examining specific characters can further illustrate the differences between the two adaptations.
Edward Elric
Edward Elric, the protagonist, displays a more aggressive and impulsive personality in the original series. “Brotherhood” portrays him with greater depth, showcasing his growth and maturity throughout the series.
Alphonse Elric
Alphonse, Edward’s younger brother, is depicted as more passive in the original adaptation. In “Brotherhood,” he exhibits a stronger presence, showcasing his own struggles and development alongside Edward.
Scar
Scar, the vengeful Ishvalan, is given a more sympathetic portrayal in “Brotherhood.” His motivations and tragic backstory are explored in greater detail, allowing viewers to understand his actions more fully compared to the original series.
Conclusion
Both “Fullmetal Alchemist” and “Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood” offer unique interpretations of the same source material. While the original adaptation provides a distinct narrative with its own merits, “Brotherhood” stands out for its fidelity to the manga and its deeper exploration of characters and themes. Ultimately, the choice between the two adaptations may come down to personal preference, but understanding their differences enriches the viewing experience for fans and newcomers alike.